| OFFENSIVE LINE | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Ben Barten | Stratford | 6' 5" | 255 | JR |
| Tyler Cooper | Saint Croix Falls | 6' 5" | 315 | SR |
| Bradon Gulch | Berlin | 6' 0" | 270 | SR |
| Jacob Schrauth | Saint Mary's Springs | 6' 3" | 235 | SR |
| Logan Zschernitz | Spencer/Columbus Catholic | 6' 4" | 300 | SR |
| OFFENSIVE BACKS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Leo Chenal | Grantsburg | 6' 3" | 235 | SR |
| Darios Crawley-Reid | Martin Luther | 5' 8" | 185 | SR |
| Bryce Huettner | Iola-Scandinavia | 5' 10" | 215 | SR |
| Brady Redwine | Elk Mound | 6' 0" | 185 | SR |
| Dane Vance | Lake Country Lutheran | 5' 11" | 185 | SR |
| QUARTERBACKS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Ben Bates | Newman Catholic | 6’ 1” | 210 | JR |
| Da'Shaun Brown | Racine St. Catherine's | 6' 1" | 180 | SR |
| Mitch Waechter | Saint Mary's Springs | 6' 3" | 185 | SR |
| WIDE RECEIVERS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Morgan Carpenter | Palmyra-Eagle | 6' 3" | 190 | SR |
| Brayden Holzemer | Cuba City | 6' 2" | 175 | SR |
| TE/FB | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Andrew Ernstmeyer | Regis | 6' 2" | 215 | SR |
| DEFENSIVE LINEMEN | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Ben Barten | Stratford | 6' 5" | 255 | JR |
| Adrian Garcia | Racine St. Catherine's | 5' 10" | 250 | SR |
| DEFENSIVE ENDS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Daryl Carter | Racine St. Catherine's | 5' 11" | 250 | SR |
| Logan Zschernitz | Spencer/Columbus Catholic | 6' 4" | 300 | SR |
| INSIDE LINEBACKERS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Leo Chenal | Grantsburg | 6' 3" | 235 | SR |
| Carson Hildebrandt | Spencer/Columbus Catholic | 5' 8" | 175 | SR |
| Levi Jensen | Luck | 5'10" | 205 | JR |
| Jeremy Jorns | Sevastopol | 6'1" | 195 | SR |
| Ryan Larson | Saint Croix Central | 6' 1" | 220 | SR |
| OUTSIDE LINEBACKERS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Andrew Ernstmeyer | Regis | 6' 2" | 215 | SR |
| Jake Hoch | Saint Mary's Springs | 6' 3" | 190 | JR |
| Gervase Thompson IV | Northwestern | 6' 1" | 225 | SR |
| DEFENSIVE BACKS | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Karson Butt | Edgar | 5' 11" | 182 | SR |
| Bryce Haertle | Lake Country Lutheran | 6' 2" | 175 | SR |
| Teagan Herschleb | Columbus | 6' 2" | 160 | JR |
| Austin Kopacz | Saint Croix Central | 6' 0" | 175 | SR |
| PUNTER | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Derrick Myer | Saint Croix Central | 6' 0" | 190 | SR |
| KICKER | School | Ht | Wt. | Year |
| Curtis Cox | Mineral Point | 5' 11" | 175 | SR |
2018 WFCA Small School Offensive Player of the Year:
Leo Chenal, Grantsburg, RB
2018 WFCA Small School Defensive Player of the Year:
Leo Chenal, Grantsburg, LB